Not that long ago, plastic housewraps like Tyvek and Typar replaced organic felt paper as the standard siding underlayment. Now there's a new generation of synthetic roofing underlayments poised to displace felt paper up on the roof. To find out whether their advantages justify their higher prices, I recently gathered together as many of these roofing membranes as I could find.

Along with roofing contractor Martin Elle, who's a strong advocate of 30-pound felt-paper underlayment, I designed a simple field test to compare roofing underlayments from an installer's point of view and get an idea of how they perform.

or Register to read the full article.