RRP Discussion Continues
In his answer to my letter (“Interpreting the RRP,” 4/12), Shawn McCadden writes that “there seems to be a lot of confusion surrounding the EPA definition of ‘demolition’” (“Lead Paint Rules Require Context,” 5/12). No kidding! But he stirs the pot again, by first correctly stating that the RRP rules apply to both painted and coated surfaces but then incorrectly assuming that paneling materials would need to be disturbed during demolition, writing that “demolition of those materials would fall under the rule unless it has been established by testing that there is no lead present.”
Not so fast! I have been remodeling for 30 years and have removed thousands of square feet of paneling by barely disturbing the finish at all. I would venture to guess that between all the remodeling jobs I have ever done that involved removing paneling, I still haven’t disturbed more than 6 square feet of finish. Most paneling and trim can be removed wholly intact because it’s fastened with light-gauge finish nails or brads.
William Wiehe Jr.
Vice Versa Builders
Fairfax, Va.
