Boston's Troubled Triple-Deckers May Offer
Opportunity~
They're a hallmark of vernacular architecture in Boston,
Mass., and in other cities along the New England coast: the
three-story structures that sprang up, shoulder to shoulder, to
serve as worker housing during the region's industrial boom in
the late 1800s and early 1900s. With three apartments stacked
up around a single staircase and hallway, the classic New
England three-decker can hold three young families (or an
undetermined number of college students).
Typical three-deckers are a traditional income property,
ideal in good times for a landlord investor (sometimes, with
the owner occupying one unit and renting the rest out). But
these are bad times for real estate, and in Boston and
vicinity, as cash flow fails and investors bail, many old
three-deckers, foreclosed or abandoned, are contributing to
urban blight in bad parts of town. The New York Times covers
the story in
"
Hard Times for New England’s 3-Deckers," by Abby
Goodnough. "In Boston,” writes Goodnough, three-family
homes represent 14 percent of the housing stock, but made up 21
percent of foreclosed property in 2008, according to the
city’s Department of Neighborhood Development."
In New Bedford, Mass., officials are starting to tear down
blighted three-deckers. But in Boston, Mayor Thomas Menino has
endorsed a policy of preserving the buildings as affordable
housing. Menino, the Times reports, has a soft spot in his
heart for the triple-deckers, a familiar element of his youth
in the predominantly Italian Boston neighborhood of Hyde Park.
It's a sentiment echoed by author Dennis Lehane, who grew up in
Boston's Dorchester neighborhood and gave the three-decker a
place in novels such as
Mystic River, the source for the 2003 Clint
Eastwood-directed
movie
of the same name, starring Sean Penn, Tim Robbins, and Kevin
Bacon.
In support of his vision, Mayor Menino points to a current
developer project to rehab a row of foreclosed three-deckers on
Dorchester's Hendry Street. The New York Times covers the
Dorchester story in
"
Communities Become Home Buyers to Fight Decay," by Vikas
Bajaj.
Nationally, activists are gaining top-level attention for
the concept of turning older urban low-rise building stock into
high-performance green, energy-efficient housing. One advocate
of this approach, activist Van Jones, proposes training
inner-city youth to do the work, to provide job growth,
housing, and community building within the scope of a single
initiative. Jones has the ear of powerful Washington interests,
including House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, according to an extensive
profile in the New Yorker magazine
("
Greening the Ghetto," by Elizabeth Kolbert). Jones has been
pushing his philosophy in the heart of triple-decker country,
New Bedford, Mass., and the surge of energy-efficiency stimulus
money — along with the Federal tax credit for
first-time home buyers — could serve to put some cash
behind the concept.
For green remodelers, the triple-decker offers some
advantages. Simple in concept, the homes are cookie-cutter
similar — so with a couple of jobs under your belt,
you can almost turn the projects into a routine. And if it's
high-performance energy-efficiency you want, the triple-decker
is an ideal starting point, according to Boston-based remodeler
Paul
Eldrenkamp, who chaired Massachusetts Governor Deval
Patrick's task force on
zero-energy
housing.
Says Eldrenkamp, "Three-deckers with flat roofs represent a
golden opportunity for deep energy retrofits — their
simple exterior geometry makes it easy to add a foot or more of
insulation to the exterior; and flat roofs make it easy to
provide optimum orientation for solar panels. They also have
very favorable surface-area-to-volume ratios, and are often in
neighborhoods well served by public transportation. If we could
get organized, we could turn whole neighborhoods into net
energy producers."