It was the summer of 1977. I'd just received my education
degree, but I wasn't ready to begin my "professional" career.
So I decided to take on a construction project.
With only a few summers' worth of construction experience but
a lot of youthful ambition, I planned to dismantle a large
colonial home and rebuild it elsewhere for a customer. I
enlisted a buddy — another recent college graduate
— to help.
It was during this project that I discovered what I wanted to
do with my life. When we started stripping plaster and pulling
up floor coverings, we found beautiful hand-hewn timbers
connected by tight interlocking joinery. During demolition I
uncovered an 1826 Liberty Head penny left by a craftsman more
than 150 years before. That penny would provide my future
company with its name, Liberty Head Post and Beam.
Almost 30 years later, I'm still intrigued by the beauty and
structural integrity of a tight-fitting timber frame, and
regular phone calls from would-be apprentices indicate I'm not
alone. Unlike many construction businesses, I have no trouble
finding and keeping bright, ambitious employees; several of our
eight crew members have been with the company 10 years or
more.
At first I focused mostly on dismantling and reassembling
historic buildings, but within a few years I started building
my own timber frames. I learned a lot about joinery from old
buildings; even in the early years it was clear to me that not
all timber frames are created equal. The better frames were
built with joints that resisted twisting of the members as they
dried, and they were hewn from rot-resistant woods.
Wood Species
Timber frames can be constructed from just about any wood
species, but most of our frames are made from Eastern hemlock
or Douglas fir. Both of these softwoods are easy to work with
yet very strong and dimensionally stable. Hemlock is a
traditional choice in our area and the material comes from
local suppliers, which appeals to some customers.
Douglas fir is popular because it's a handsome reddish-brown
color and has an interesting grain. I like it because it's easy
to get — I usually have a truck of timber a week after
placing an order with the suppliers in my area — and we
can get it grade-stamped for commercial projects. It costs
about twice as much as hemlock, primarily because it has to be
trucked from the West Coast. But since most of a frame's cost
is labor, the additional expense adds only about 10 percent to
the overall job.
Another attribute of hemlock and fir is that they generally
don't twist or check badly as they dry. To further prevent
checking, we coat any end grain with Anchorseal end sealer
(U.C. Coatings, 888/363-2628,
www.uccoatings.com). The waxy coating slows
drying, which helps keep checks and splits to a minimum.
Oak and pine. While white oak
has long been considered one of the best materials for timber
framing, it has become so expensive we seldom use it anymore.
It was never a common timber framing material in northern New
England anyway; the climate is too cold to support large stands
of white oak.
Over the last 20 years I've seen an increase in the use of
white pine for timber framing. Timber framers who are using it
may disagree, but I don't think pine is the best timber-frame
material. In my experience, pine won't tolerate the additional
stress caused by drawbore pegging (using a 1/8-inch offset
between the holes on the tenon and the holes on the mortise so
that the framing members are drawn together as the peg is
driven through the joint). Pine tends to split as the peg is
driven.
Also, in all my years of dismantling and rebuilding historic
structures, we have never come across pine frames or
components. I can only conclude that either the pine frames
didn't survive long enough to be salvaged, or the timber
framers of the time didn't think pine was an appropriate
material. Certainly the reason isn't that pine was in short
supply: The sheathing, flooring, and millwork were almost
always pine.
Joinery
The key to timber framing is the mortise-and-tenon joint. We
use fully housed tenons; the housing is a recess about 1/2 inch
to 3/4 inch deep that receives the framing member with the
tenon (see Figure 1). This joint takes longer to make, but it
prevents the timbers from twisting as they dry and allows us to
compensate for slight variations in the dimensions of
timbers.
Figure 1. Housed mortises — like
the one in the post cut to receive the knee brace (A) —
help prevent members from twisting as they dry. Rafters have an
interlocking joint at the top plate (B) and a pegged
mortise-and-tenon joint at the peak (C). Long members, like
plates that run the length of a wall, are made with scarf
joints (D).
We also use scarf joints to join shorter timbers into tie
beams and top plates, which are the longest members in a house
frame. We use a compound cut at rafter ends, too, which
provides greater uplift and thrust resistance than a typical
birdsmouth. All joints are secured with tapered white oak pegs.
As I mentioned earlier, we use drawbore pegging for mortises
and tenons.
Tools of the Trade
Any carpenter would recognize our most commonly used hand
tools. The only difference would be that our tools are a little
bigger than those used by stick framers and seem to cost a lot
more.
When raising a frame, we carry both conventional framing
hammers and medium-sized mallets with replaceable rawhide faces
(Figure 2). We keep large mallets called commanders within
reach for more stubborn timbers.
Figure 2. Specialized power tools from
Mafell — a chain mortiser (A) and an oversized planer (B)
and circular saw (C) — speed the prepping of timbers in
the shop. On site, the crew uses a collection of large wood
mallets (D) and smaller rawhide mallets (E) to nudge timbers
into place, and large chisels (F) for fine-tuning joints. Most
important of all, the company's boom truck (G) handles delivery
and heavy lifting.
We also use folding pruning saws for cutting pegs, and large
framing chisels for fine-tuning the joinery. We have dozens of
rigging straps of all lengths, which we use for lifting timbers
with the crane or tugging them with come-alongs. We have at
least 20 come-alongs on site for tightening joints, pulling
bents, and moving anything that needs a little
persuasion.
Power tools. We mainly use
power tools when we're building a frame in the shop. Pulling a
power tool from our trailer on site usually means that we made
a mistake at the shop. But problems do arise, so we always
carry a chain mortiser, a large power plane, a router for
easing edges, and a 14-inch circular saw. Most of our power
tools are made by a German company, Mafell (888/736-3812,
www.mafell.com), which specializes in the
timber-frame trade.
Don't forget the crane. We
have our own truck-mounted crane for delivery and assembly. The
truck has a 20-foot body, but we can move timbers longer than
30 feet if we need to.
The crane can lift as much as 5,000 pounds while extended 45
feet, or 1,000 pounds (roughly the weight of a large
preassembled dormer) at its maximum extension of 80 feet.
Raising a Frame
We start by assembling the bent (a vertical section of the
frame) farthest away from the truck. A bent commonly includes
the first-floor posts, a tie beam that carries the second-floor
joists, the second-floor posts, and the rafters (Figure
3).
Figure 3. A bent commonly includes every
member from the first-floor posts to the rafters. Connecting
girts run perpendicular between bents.
We rarely assemble the whole thing at once, as it would be too
big and unwieldy. More often, we start with the first-floor
posts and the second-floor beams.
We pay close attention to how we load the truck so we can pull
those components without moving a lot of other pieces. Tie
beams, which are generally made in two sections, go together
first. Then we install the posts and knee braces. Knee braces
provide some racking resistance and cut the length of the span,
but perhaps most important they give the frame its traditional
look.
Most of our frames are built over a modern floor system made
from sawn or engineered lumber. While it's possible to attach
the posts on top of the subfloor, we prefer to cut pockets
through the subflooring and rest the post bases directly on the
mudsill (Figure 4). This helps prevent the posts from twisting
as they dry out. Twisting posts not only look bad, but they can
crack tile and make finish carpentry difficult.
Figure 4. Assembling a frame starts with
the bent farthest from the crane (top and middle). Carefully
sized pockets in the subfloor (top) will receive the posts
— a detail the author likes because it provides good
bearing directly onto the sill and also helps prevent the posts
from twisting.
Using the pockets also provides a better structural
connection, because the outer posts can be nailed or screwed
through the band joist to resist uplift forces. The pockets
make assembly faster, too, because they secure the bottoms of
the posts during the frame raising.
We almost always have to enlarge at least one hole or trim a
post bottom, but most of the GCs we work with do a good job of
locating the pockets when they frame the floor, based on our
drawings.
We lift and guide the bent into position with the crane, and
then we brace it with dimensional lumber.
Once we have craned the second bent into position, we use
come-alongs to spread the bents so we can drop the connecting
beams — called girts — between them (Figure
5).
Figure 5. After a pair of bents has been
raised and braced (top), the crew uses come-alongs and the
crane to cautiously spread the bents, coax the tenoned girts
into their mortises, then pull the bents back together (middle
and bottom).
Second floor. When all the
bents are raised, we bring in the second-floor joists in pairs
so we can place them two at a time. Framers stationed at both
ends of the joist guide them into place.
Top plates are next (Figure 6). Same as in stick framing, they
form the top of the wall and receive the eaves ends of the
rafters. Once the top plates are in place, the frame starts to
feel sturdy.
Figure 6. Assembly continues with the
second-story posts and connecting plates (top), which are
mortised to receive the rafters (bottom left). Braces are
nailed along the outside of the perimeter posts, where the nail
holes will not be visible (bottom right).
Queen posts and queen-post ties follow. These assemblies rest
on the tie beam and, along with the purlins, create midspan
support for the rafters.
Rafters and Dormers
Using pairs of rigging straps, we lift up the rafters one at a
time. Bringing each rafter in at the approximate roof angle
makes installation easier. The rafters have a compound
birdsmouth cut at the eaves end, and a mortise-and-tenon joint
at the ridge. We fasten them midspan and at the eaves with long
ring nails commonly used in pole-building construction (Figure
7).
Figure 7. With small cleats tacked on top
to prevent the straps from sliding, the rafters are lifted into
place one at a time (A). After opposing rafters are pegged at
the top, they are nailed to midspan purlins with long
ring-shank nails (B). A gable dormer completes the frame (C,
D).
The house shown in the photos had one shed dormer and one
gable dormer. The GC chose to stick-frame the shed dormer, and
we built the gable dormer. We preassembled much of the dormer
on the ground and then lifted the assembly in one piece.
Once a few more rafters were installed over the dormer and a
pine bough was placed at the ridge, the frame was
complete.
Exterior Finishes
At this point my work is done and the GC takes over. Though
stress-skin panels are often used for the rest of the project,
I prefer stick framing for several reasons: First, it's easier
to run mechanicals and make changes and additions with studded
walls.
Second, I've had customers tell me that the stress-skin panels
don't stop outside noise like traffic or barking dogs as well
as an insulated stick-framed house does. And finally, carpenter
ants seem to love nesting in stress-skin panels.
For the house shown, the GC used stress-skin panels for the
roof and stick framed the walls with 2x6s. He insulated the
walls with spray polyurethane foam. The timber frame was kept 6
inches from the building line to make room for stud walls
around the bents.
Duncan Keir owns Liberty Head Post and
Beam in Huntington, Vt.