Contractors who have spent years trying to make money often
fail to think about how they will protect their assets once
it's time to sell or close down the business. But this decision
has important legal ramifications, and your goal should be to
do it in the cleanest possible manner.
While there are several ways to leave a business, the most
common is to simply close the doors or transfer it to someone
else, usually by sale. Many of the issues involved in closing a
business are routine, like paying taxes and notifying
customers. You'll need to close out accounts with vendors and
formally terminate your licenses and leases. Don't assume that
licenses will lapse on their own: Some states will come after
you for past-due registration fees.
Reducing Long-Term Liability
Just as it takes planning to protect your assets while you're
in business, the same is true once the business is closed or
sold. Here in California, there's a particularly high hurdle to
clear — a 10-year statute of limitations for latent
construction defects. A contractor's clients and their
successors have up to 10 years to sue GCs for latent defects,
which are most frequently related to water intrusion. The
periods of legal exposure are shorter for other kinds of
complaints, but typically a contractor can be sued for breach
of contract or breach of warranty for up to four years after
completion of the project.
As an attorney, I am concerned less about the exact defect than
about the fact that my clients are at risk for
10 years, even after they retire or sell the business. There
are similar liability laws in other states. The precise rules
vary by state, and different types of liability are subject to
different statutes of limitations, but typically a builder is
exposed to liability for between three and six years after a
project's completion.
In some cases, the clock does not start ticking until the
defect is discovered. Contractors are frequently subject to a
different set of rules than other businesses, so to be certain,
check with a local attorney who specializes in construction
law.
Sole owner vs. corporation. How to best protect yourself when
you close or sell depends on the kind of business entity you
have — sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, or
limited liability company (LLC). Most of my clients have sole
proprietorships or corporations, so I'll stick to those in this
article.
Closing Down a Sole
Proprietorship
The sole proprietor typically faces the most difficult —
and expensive — choices. One possibility is to
"self-insure," which is another way of saying to cross your
fingers and hope for the best. If problems arise with past
construction projects, you'll have to either make the repairs,
pay someone else to make them, or pay the clients if they
prevail against you in a lawsuit. In some circumstances, you
could be forced to pay the attorney fees for both sides.
Considering all the things that can go wrong on a construction
project, I would never recommend that a sole proprietor
self-insure. If things go truly wrong, all your personal assets
will be at risk.
Tail insurance. One way to protect yourself is by purchasing a
"tail policy" from your insurance company if one is available.
Tail coverage protects you against claims stemming from
projects completed in the past. It's expensive, but if you've
done a steady volume of work, the rates should fall as the
clock winds down on the projects covered. A tail policy needs
to run for as long as the statute of limitations, and will
usually cover only liability related to construction defects;
it will not cover breach of warranty or breach of
contract.
Semiretirement an option. Another possibility would be to
maintain your current liability policy. This could be a good
strategy for a couple of reasons. First, in some states, defect
litigation has made tail policies hard to get. Also, as an
insurance broker recently told me, most contractors never
really retire: Keeping your policy in place while doing
occasional jobs as a "semiretired" builder can be an attractive
option.
Selling a Sole Proprietorship
Skipping the practical problem of finding a buyer, if you do
sell you can create an agreement that apportions risk for
claims. It's common practice for a buyer to accept the business
"as is," including liability for past actions. This isn't as
strange as it sounds: In many cases, the buyer is a longtime
employee who is in a position to know the quality of past
work.
Indemnification. The sales contract will typically contain an
indemnity clause, a negotiated agreement about who will pay for
problems that arise on past projects. Because it's negotiated,
the party with the most leverage tends to get the best
protection. If the seller is calling the shots, the sale will
probably be "as is" and he will be indemnified by the buyer. If
the buyer is calling the shots, it will be the other way
around.
Insurance also plays a role. There is less risk if the company
being sold has always been covered by a liability policy. If
the existing policy remains in place during the ownership
change, that too will mitigate risk. It would be up to the
insurance broker to decide whether to cover the company once it
changes hands.
Closing Down a Corporation
Contractors who incorporate usually do so to protect their
personal noncorporate assets during the time they are in
business. If the shareholders dissolve the corporation when
they shut down the business, they place themselves in the same
boat as the sole proprietor. The corporation will no longer
shield them from liability. Thus, unless the new owners
purchase a tail policy, they will have to self-insure.
It's perhaps better for the shareholders to keep the
corporation going until all the statutes of limitations or
potential claims against them have expired. The shareholders
would continue to file their yearly paperwork with the state
and pay the required yearly fee. The corporation would have no
income, so only the minimum tax would be due. Here in
California, the annual tax is $800 — a lot less than a
tail policy, and a small price to pay to protect your assets.
Additionally, the shareholders could opt for the "belt and
suspenders" approach and add a tail policy, too.
Selling a Corporation
When you sell a corporation, you are selling corporate shares.
The most likely buyer would be an employee, a competitor, or
another shareholder. Corporations are chartered by individual
states, so there are probably as many rules governing the sale
of corporate stock as there are states. Because of this and the
absolute need for some kind of written agreement, both parties
should consult attorneys when a corporation changes
hands.
Bryant H. Byrneshas a law practice in Oakland, Calif.,
that specializes in construction law.