Thickened-edge slabs make practical foundations where soils
are stable. But building codes mandate special foundation
designs in areas with expansive soils, because seasonal
swelling and shrinking of the soil can cause significant
cracking of both the foundation and the structure it supports.
A proven solution for these conditions is a post-tensioned
slab, which uses a grid of high-tensile steel cables —
rather than conventional wire mesh or rebar — to
provide strength and control cracking.
The reinforcing cables and their specialized end fittings are
cast into the center of the slab before the pour. After the
concrete has cured for a few days, each cable, known as a
tendon, is stretched with a hydraulic ram, placing slab and
footings under compression. The tendons are sheathed with a
tough plastic that prevents them from bonding to the concrete;
a coating of lubricant between the sheath and the cable inside
allows the cable to stretch freely during the tensioning
process. This pre-compression lets the foundation behave like a
prestressed concrete beam in resisting the tensile loads
imposed by soil uplift or subsidence.
Post-tensioned slabs have been used since the 1960s but have
become more common over the past two decades. As a structural
engineer with a California firm that designs hundreds of
post-tensioned residential slabs each year, I've found that
they're simple to build, economical, and reliable.
Soil Conditions
California and Texas are well known for their expansive clay
soils, but similar soil conditions are found across a wide
swath of the central Great Plains and in pockets of varying
size nationwide.
Expansive soils are an especially serious problem in areas
with wide seasonal variations in soil moisture content. During
hot, dry summer weather, clay soils shrink, while extended
periods of wetter weather cause the soil to expand. Since the
slab itself tends to protect the soil directly beneath from
wetting and drying, most swelling and shrinking take place at
the edges (see Figure 1). Determining the expansiveness of a
given soil is a job for a qualified geotechnical
engineer.
Figure 1.The "Ym" value of a soil can
be thought of as a measure of its potential for expansion: the
higher the value, the greater the soil movement as conditions
swing from wet to dry and back again. The "em"
value, which describes the distance inward from the slab edge
that the soil moisture can be expected to vary, is mostly a
function of the local climate.
Measuring soil
expansiveness. In designing a foundation, two variables
covered in the soils report are especially relevant to the
structural engineer. The first is the Ym value, or
Differential Swell, which refers to the extreme range of soil
movement that could occur. (Like other worst-case engineering
values, this number expresses a possibility and doesn't mean
that that much movement will occur.) Differential Swell is
expressed in inches. A value of 4 or less indicates that the
soil can support a properly designed post-tensioned slab.
If the Ym figure is higher than 4, a geotechnical
engineer will need to develop a different — and
generally more costly — foundation plan. One common
approach would be to bore down to bedrock or competent soil and
cast piers that support a grade-beam foundation (see
"Trouble-Free
Foundations for Expansive Soils," 11/02).
Moisture penetration. The
second key value is what's known as the Edge Moisture Variation
Distance, or em. This refers to the distance inward
from the edge of the slab that the soil moisture content can be
expected to vary. As you would expect, this number is largely a
function of local climate: The wetter the conditions, the
farther moisture can be expected to penetrate; the drier the
conditions, the wider the area of drying. The higher the
em value, the greater the stresses acting on the
slab. A good source for more information is Design and
Construction of Post-Tensioned Slabs-on-Ground (Post-Tensioning
Institute, Phoenix, Ariz.; 602/870-7540,
www.post-tensioning.org).
Uniform-Thickness vs. Ribbed
Slabs
There are two basic types of post-tensioned residential slabs.
Uniform-thickness slabs are typically about 9 inches thick
throughout, except at the perimeter footings and where isolated
footings are needed to accept heavy point loads or provide
extra embedment depth for metal structural connectors.
Ribbed slabs, by contrast, usually measure about 5 inches
thick but contain an internal grid of thicker footings that
give them a waffle-shaped cross section. These ribs can be
placed up to 17 feet apart in each direction and are required
to extend from one slab edge to the other. They're typically
located under walls or posts, so their placement is tied to
architectural drawings. In addition to providing strength and
stiffness against expansive soil movement, the ribs can be used
to anchor metal connectors and shear walls.
Slab loading. Although heavy
structural loads are usually carried by footings,
post-tensioned slabs are strong enough to carry moderate loads
directly. When planning for point loads, a safe rule of thumb
is to figure on 1,000 pounds per inch of slab thickness. A
5-inch post-tensioned slab can handle up to 5,000 pounds, and a
typical 9-inch-thick slab will bear a concentrated 9,000-pound
load. In addition, both the International Building Code and the
Uniform Building Code provide design methods for determining
the capacity of a post-tensioned slab to support the load from
a bearing wall. Especially with a uniform-thickness slab, this
may make it possible to do away with interior footings
entirely.
Labor and materials.
Uniform-thickness slabs have the advantage of simplicity. Most
of the trenching is limited to the exterior footings, which
helps keep labor costs down. On the other hand,
uniform-thickness slabs require more concrete. Plus, because
the minimum number of tendons for the slab is determined by its
cross-sectional area, the uniform-thickness slab will also
require more tendons than a thinner ribbed slab of the same
square footage.
In practice, either approach can be used to satisfy the
strength and stiffness criteria of the code. We find that most
builders simply go with the version they're most familiar
with.
Excavation and Forms
Except for the reinforcing, post-tensioned slabs are excavated
and formed exactly like conventional residential slabs. Once
the site has been cleared of vegetation and other organic
material, the slab is laid out and staked, along with the
positions of any internal ribs. The clay soils we work with are
generally solid and hard, so vertical-walled trenches readily
hold their shape (Figure 2). In looser soils, trenches must
sometimes be sloped to prevent loose material from falling into
the bottom.
Figure 2.A worker uses a rotary hammer to excavate
hard clay that forms the subgrade of a ribbed slab. The network
of intersecting trenches defines the internal footings, or
ribs, that will stiffen the slab and help it resist soil
movement.
There's a minimal danger of uplift from frost in our part of
California, so the perimeter footing only needs to be deep
enough to satisfy the soils report and to resist the vertical,
lateral, and expansive soil load of the structure. Our company
uses a minimum 18-inch embedment into the soil at the exterior
footings. The trenches that form the ribs are also about 18
inches deep.
Once the foundation crew has staked the perimeter forms in
place and braced them with diagonal kickers, they cover the
prepared subgrade with a poly vapor barrier. With a
uniform-thickness slab, it's easy to do this with a few
continuously overlapping sheets. A ribbed slab, with its
internal trenches, is a little trickier. The usual construction
practice is to cover each soil "block" with its own sheet of
poly and leave the trenched areas uncovered (Figure 3).
Figure 3.A poly vapor barrier on each soil "block"
is held in place with a layer of sand. Where plumbing or
conduit runs beneath the bottom of a rib, the excavation is
deepened and widened enough to provide the full required
thickness and bearing area above and around the buried
utility.
The poly is typically covered with a layer of sand or gravel,
as specified by the geotechnical engineer, to protect the vapor
barrier from damage when the concrete is placed and to help
with the curing of the concrete.
Tendon Layout
The exact spacing of the tendons will vary depending on the
thickness of the slab and other variables. An on-center spacing
of 3 to 4 feet or so is typical of most residential
foundations. With relatively few tendons to keep track of, the
layout is easy to inspect, and problems are easily identified
and corrected.
But the nominal tendon spacing is more an average than a hard
and fast rule. As long as the foundation contains the required
number of tendons, the exact spacing between them can be
somewhat flexible. For example, within a nominal 4-foot grid,
the actual distance between any two tendons could vary between
3 and 5 feet or so. The endmost tendons in a given run must be
located within 2 feet of the edge of the slab, but no closer to
it than 6 inches.
Dead-end attachment. For
most moderate-sized residential slabs, the precut tendons are
delivered from the supplier with a cast-iron anchor plate
permanently attached to one end (Figure 4).
Figure 4.The plastic-coated tendons arrive at the
site cut to length, with one anchor plate already wedged in
place (left). The preattached dead-end anchor is nailed to the
form board half the slab thickness from its top edge, and a
U-shaped steel backup bar is wired to the anchor to help
distribute the eventual tensioning pressure over a wider area
of the slab edge (right). The thick sleeve at the end of the
tendon is designed to protect the cable and fitting from
corrosive soils present on this site; in noncorrosive soils it
could be omitted.
The end with the attached plate, or dead end, is fastened to
the form board with two 20d nails. The tendon is then unrolled
across the subslab to the tension-end (or stressing-end) anchor
on the opposite slab edge. Tendons need not run in a completely
straight line; they can be diverted a foot or so to one side to
avoid plumbing stacks or other obstructions, as long as they
follow a gradual curve. For the 1/2-inch tendons used in most
residential slabs, the rule is not to bend the tendon to a
curve tighter than a 10-foot radius.
Pocket formers. Unlike the
anchor at the dead end, which is supported on the form board by
its nails, the tension-end anchor is mated to a hollow plastic
pocket former that fits into a hole in the form board (Figure
5).
Figure 5.Tension-end fittings are first nailed to
the forms (top) before the tendons are threaded through a hole
in the perimeter form. The hollow plastic pocket former will be
pulled out when the forms are stripped, leaving a recess for
the nosepiece of the hydraulic ram used to tension the tendons
(bottom).
The tension end of the tendon is inserted through a hole in
the cast-iron anchor and pocket former and out through the
corresponding hole in the form, leaving 2 feet or so of tendon
sticking out beyond the slab edge. Once the slab has been
poured and the forms have been stripped, the pocket formers are
removed, leaving a cavity designed to accommodate the hydraulic
ram that will later be used to stress the tendons.
For slabs longer or wider than 70 feet or so, the friction
created between the slab and the subgrade significantly reduces
the force in the tendon from one anchor to another. For these
spans and greater, anchors with pocket formers are used at both
ends so the forces can be equalized.
Additional reinforcing and connectors. As the tendons are
placed, they are wired together where they intersect and
supported by wire or plastic chairs (Figure 6).
Figure 6.Tendons are supported by plastic chairs
and wired together where they intersect (left). In some limited
areas, such as this inside corner next to a garage door
opening, conventional rebar provides added resistance to
cracking (right).
Some areas, such as inside corners or pop-outs, require the
addition of conventional rebar to minimize cracking or
reinforce the section. Once the supplementary rebar and all
required anchor bolts and structural hold-downs have been wired
in place, the site is ready for concrete.
Pouring and Tensioning the
Slab
A post-tensioned slab is poured and finished like any other
residential slab, using conventional 2,500-psi or higher
concrete with a 4- or 5-inch slump. The concrete crew pours the
perimeter footing and any interior ribs before filling the
forms the rest of the way (Figure 7).
Figure 7.The concrete crew will finish filling the
perimeter footings and internal ribs before pouring the slab.
The wide spaces between tendons make it easy to walk around on
the subgrade without tripping over the reinforcing —
something that's much harder to do on conventional slab
reinforced with wire mesh or a closely spaced rebar
grid.
The entire design philosophy of post-tensioned foundations
demands that the interior and exterior footings work with the
slab to resist any applied loads. For that to happen, it's
essential to avoid horizontal cold joints between the footings
and the slab. Most residential slabs can easily be poured
monolithically, but for larger slabs it's sometimes necessary
to use vertical construction joints to create more manageable
pour sizes.
Handle with care. The slab
may look ready to go once the forms have been stripped, but
because the tendons — unlike conventional rebar
— are unbonded to the concrete, it's effectively
unreinforced until the tendons have been stressed. Builders
often want to begin framing as soon as the forms are stripped,
a day or two after the pour, and that doesn't ordinarily pose
any problems. Foot traffic and the weight of the framed walls
typically aren't heavy enough to damage the slab. As with any
green concrete, though, it's best to avoid driving vehicles
onto the slab or subjecting it to heavy point loads.
Because there's little conventional rebar to help minimize
shrinkage cracking, it's imperative to stress the tendons as
soon as the concrete has cured enough to permit it. Our
drawings allow the contractor to stress the tendons once the
concrete has reached a minimum compressive strength of 2,000
psi. In addition, we require that the slab be stressed within
five days of the pour and that an ACI-approved curing method be
used.
Pulling the tendons. The
tendons are stressed with a portable hydraulic ram powered by
an electric motor. This is a fairly straightforward process:
The exposed strand is inserted into a slotted groove on the
bottom of the ram. Once the tendon is secure, the jack is moved
along the tendon until the tapered nosepiece presses against
the cast-iron anchor embedded in the stressing pocket. A
camming device grips the cable and stretches it when the ram is
activated (Figure 8).
Figure 8.Tendons are tensioned with a portable
hydraulic ram. The round gauge on the hydraulic power unit lets
the operator know when the required amount of force has been
reached (above left). After the newly tensioned cables have
been locked in position with steel wedges, the protruding ends
of the cables and the nails used to fasten the cast-iron
anchors to the forms are cut off with an acetylene torch (above
right). The remaining pockets will later be filled with grout
(left).
This stretching process involves enormous force and should be
done only by a qualified operator. A typical tendon in a
residential foundation is placed under 33,000 pounds of tension
— enough to stretch the 1/2-inch steel cable by 4
inches or so over a 50-foot run. A gauge on the ram lets the
operator know when the proper tension has been reached. At that
point, the main hydraulic cylinder holds the tension steady
while a pair of secondary cylinders forces two small, tapered
steel wedges into a space between the tendon and the embedded
anchor.
Double-ended pulls on longer tendons are accomplished by
temporarily wedging the tendon to the anchor at one end,
subjecting the other end to the full tensioning force and
wedging that end permanently. The ram is then brought around to
the temporarily wedged end of the tendon and stressed to the
maximum gauge pressure. Once the gauge pressure has been
reached, that end is permanently wedged, as well.
With the tensioning force locked in place by the wedges, the
ram can be removed and moved ahead to the next cable. All this
happens very quickly. A two-person crew — one to
operate the ram and another to watch the gauge pressure
— can tension a dozen or more foundations in a day. As
required by code, a building inspector is also present to
confirm that each cable is tensioned as specified and to record
the elongations of the tendons.
Grouting the pockets. Once
the tendons have been pulled and have passed inspection, the
protruding cable ends are cut off inside the stressing pockets,
an inch from the edge of the slab. There are specialized
hydraulic shears designed for this purpose, but the usual tool
of choice on residential jobs is an acetylene torch. The
protruding ends of the nails used to fasten the anchors to the
forms are torched off at the same time. Finally, the stressing
pockets are filled with grout to protect the anchors, cables,
and wedges from the weather.
Bryan Allredis a structural engineer with Seneca
Structural Engineering in Laguna Hills, Calif.